Let’s discuss: Is Modi govt’s Kashmir policy a success, failure or same old muddling along? -adsmember

Early access, exclusive content, special privileges – Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s YouTube channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA/join

,?

When you compare 30 in 1.3bln population is a small no. But if you consider 30life in 30family, it is a huge impact. If 70yrs of discussion did not yield solution then you must try something else. This is where Modi new policy comes in. If Modi new policy does not work then we must try sth new beyond these two tried methods.

Apocalypse Now for the Sanghis Gupta jee . I think they will understand the word Praleh better…meri ??baat eh ..

Let there be freedom for kadhmiris

To solve the Kashmir problem we have to destroy islam.

It's an Utter Failure !!!! Hardly a Subject to discuss ……Fact is a Fact.

Mr shekhar Gupta it's not the civilians it's non-Muslims and one more thing the way you said "if you say so, islamic jihad" shows your ideology .

Just the way Isreal's racist, bigoted, and apartheid brutality against the Palestinians has not worked in decades, India's nihilistic policies against the Kashmiries, in Kashmir are doomed. Unilateral bullying won't work, no matter how much India emulates Isreal. Kashmiries should determine their own fate. Not Mr Gupta from his ivory tower, and certainly not by the leader of a race baiting party. India, you can do better!

Wonderful Analysis.

Create a buffer state Khalistan between two arch nuclear powered enemies..

any attempt to change religious demography of kashmir shall be responded in a violent manner so modi govt should top israel tactic of settlement and start being a good bou

Very fair and insightful commentary.

Very well articulated ?

That is the result when nationalism overtakes so called ace journalist GOOD LUCK.

The Kashmir issue does not appear to have existed from 70s to 3s

Dear. Sir. You are a rare journalistic specimen to keep cool on hot topics Wish you a long career ahead giving us the readers a rare chance to make a balanced study of complex subjects RKSundaram

Isn't Aurangzeb responsible for the Kashmir situation?

Seakar you are Prefactily (Right) person

I wonder if anti-BJP or nonsupporters would support the current govt if they go into Kashmir with an iron fist? There will be collateral damage as with any army operation and the optics won't be good but can anyone make sure opposition parties will give full support for such an operation? The Achilles heel of the BJP is their Hinduvita image!

The permanent solution lies in dividing Pakistan into at least three pieces (three individual countries).

There is one way actually, what if Indian army targets all ?‍♀️? of Kashmir?? Don’t touch the men BUT only the ?. That way, an abrupt stop to the population can be achieved. Also this can be done using iron supplements for pregnant women. Just manipulate all iron and frolic acid supplements for the pregnant in Kashmir to achieve the required goal. Later this can be stated as manufacturing defect or something else on international stage… if it makes it there…

Idk, India must take notes from china’s Xinjiang. Sometimes certain measures are required to maintain order. I hope BJP also takes notes from CCP. 75yrs of freedom is enough, it’s time for India to become a powerhouse and democracy/secularism is the last thing which will help that goal.

Bla bla blab bla. U r kidding urself. India will need to leave Kashmir. All of Kashmir belongs to Pakistan.

i am a bjp supporter
but modi and amit are cowards

u r generalising us wrong!

Is 10 years enough to solve an 80 year “problem”, perpetuated by design by vested interest? Just asking. Should we ask the Q in a different way? Are we expecting too much in a short period and defeating the purpose of Nation building? Some more questions.

Tailpiece: I feel the media at times use improbable language for TRP. Time for a cut the clutter on over expectations etc.